Susan Smith: Biography, the 1994 Case, Trial, Prison and Parole Explained

Susan Smith: Biography, the 1994 Case, Trial, Prison and Parole Explained

Susan Smith: Biography, the 1994 Case, Trial, Prison and Parole Explained

Susan Smith is one of the most searched names in American true crime, and interest rises every time her parole status is reviewed. Her case began in Union, South Carolina, in October 1994.

This biography explains who she is, what happened to her sons Michael and Alexander, and how the case moved through investigation, trial, and prison. It also covers her parole hearings in 2024 and 2026.

Every fact below is drawn from court reporting and established news coverage of the case. Where accounts differ, the article follows the version supported by the strongest sources.

Susan Smith at a Glance

DetailInformation
Full nameSusan Leigh Smith (née Vaughan)
BornSeptember 26, 1971, Union, South Carolina, U.S.
Known forThe 1994 murders of her two sons in Union, South Carolina
VictimsMichael Daniel Smith (age 3) and Alexander Tyler Smith (14 months)
ConvictionMurder (2 counts), July 1995
SentenceTwo concurrent life terms; parole possible after 30 years
Imprisoned atLeath Correctional Institution, Greenwood, South Carolina
ParoleDenied November 20, 2024; denied again November 19, 2026
StatusIncarcerated

Who Is Susan Smith?

Susan Smith is a South Carolina woman convicted of murdering her two young sons in 1994. She was 23 years old, working as a secretary, and in the middle of a divorce when the crimes happened.

Her case drew international attention for two reasons. First, her victims were her own small children. Second, she spent nine days publicly blaming a carjacker who did not exist.

More than three decades later, she remains in prison serving life sentences. Her name returns to the news each time the South Carolina parole board reviews her case.

Susan Smith Early Life and Family Background

Susan Leigh Vaughan was born on September 26, 1971, in Union, South Carolina. Her childhood was marked by loss: her father died by suicide when she was six years old.

According to published accounts of her background, she attempted suicide at age 13. Her mother later married Beverly C. Russell Jr., who was reported to have molested Susan during her teenage years.

She graduated from high school in 1989. She married David Smith in 1991, and the couple had two sons, Michael Daniel, born in 1991, and Alexander Tyler, born in 1993.

By 1994 she was working as a secretary at Conso Products in Union. That September, she filed for divorce from David, and the marriage was formally ended in May 1995.

The Night of October 25, 1994

On the night of October 25, 1994, Susan drove her 1990 maroon Mazda Protégé to a boat ramp at John D. Long Lake, outside Union. Her sons were strapped into their car seats.

She let the car roll down the ramp into the water with Michael, aged three, and Alexander, aged 14 months, still inside. Both boys drowned in the submerged car.

Smith then went to a nearby house and reported a very different story. She told police that a Black man had carjacked her at a red light and driven away with her children.

The False Carjacking Claim and the Nine-Day Search

For nine days, the case was treated as a kidnapping. Susan appeared on national television, tearfully pleading for the safe return of Michael and Alexander as searches spread nationwide.

Investigators, however, doubted her account early on. One problem was her description of the traffic light, which would only have turned red if another vehicle had been present at the intersection.

She also faced a polygraph test as inconsistencies grew. Detectives searched area lakes and ponds, including John D. Long Lake, while continuing to press her about the missing boys.

The false claim also caused wider harm. By blaming an unnamed Black man, the story played on racial stereotypes, a point that has remained part of discussions of this case ever since.

The Confession on November 3, 1994

On November 3, 1994, nine days after the boys disappeared, Smith confessed to Union County Sheriff Howard Wells. She admitted there had been no carjacking and no kidnapping.

She told investigators what she had done at the lake. Divers then recovered her car from John D. Long Lake, about 122 feet from shore, with the boys still strapped inside.

Smith was charged with two counts of murder and was formally indicted on December 12, 1994. The case then moved toward one of the most closely watched trials in South Carolina history.

Prosecutors later argued that a letter from Tom Findlay, dated October 17, 1994, mattered. Findlay, whom she had been seeing, ended their relationship in it and said he did not want children.

Smith has maintained that there was no motive and that the killings were not planned. In a 2015 letter to The State newspaper, she wrote that something went very wrong that night.

Aerial view of John D. Long Lake in Union County, South Carolina, showing the bridge and the memorial point

The 1995 Trial and Life Sentence

Smith’s trial took place in Union in July 1995, before Judge William Howard. Prosecutor Tommy Pope sought the death penalty, arguing she killed the boys to pursue a new life.

Her defense lawyers, David Bruck and Judy Clarke, presented her as deeply troubled. A defense psychiatrist diagnosed her with dependent personality disorder and major depression.

The defense argued she had driven to the lake intending to kill herself as well. The jury still convicted her, taking about two and a half hours on July 22, 1995.

Jurors then rejected the death penalty. On July 28, 1995, Smith was sentenced to two concurrent life terms in prison, with the possibility of parole after serving 30 years.

Susan Smith in a blue dress with a white lace collar, escorted in handcuffs during her 1995 murder trial in Union, South Carolina

Susan Smith in Prison

Smith began her sentence on July 28, 1995, at the Camille Griffin Graham Correctional Institution in Columbia, South Carolina. She has now spent more than three decades behind bars.

Her prison years have included disciplinary problems alongside long quiet periods. Those incidents were later reviewed by the parole board as part of her overall record.

Disciplinary Incidents and Transfer to Leath

In 2000, two correctional officers at Camille Griffin Graham were charged in connection with sexual contact with Smith. Guard Houston Cagle pleaded guilty, and Captain Alfred Rowe later pleaded guilty as well.

Following those incidents, Smith was transferred to the Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood. Prison records reported by People show further infractions between 2010 and 2017, including drug use and self-mutilation.

In October 2024, weeks before her first parole hearing, she was found guilty of communicating with a victim or witness. The charge followed phone calls with a documentary filmmaker, and she lost privileges.

The 2024 Parole Hearing: Denied

Smith first became eligible for parole in November 2024, after serving 30 years of her life sentence. She appeared before the South Carolina parole board by video on November 20, 2024.

At the hearing, she told the board she knew what she did was horrible and asked for mercy. The boys’ father, David Smith, urged the board to keep her in prison.

The board voted unanimously to deny parole. Under South Carolina rules, a denied prisoner in her position can be reconsidered every two years.

Susan Smith appearing by video link at her November 2024 South Carolina parole hearing

The 2026 Parole Hearing: Denied Again

Smith’s second parole hearing was held on Thursday, November 19, 2026. She again appeared by video from prison, and she needed a two-thirds vote of the seven-member board to be released.

David Smith and the original prosecutors again asked the board to refuse her release. As the Greenville News reported, the board voted unanimously to deny parole for a second time.

The decision means Smith remains in prison. She will be eligible to ask the parole board again in two years, following the same review cycle.

Where Is Susan Smith Now?

Susan Smith is incarcerated at the Leath Correctional Institution near Greenwood, South Carolina. Now 55, she continues to serve two concurrent life sentences for the murders of Michael and Alexander.

Her status remains unchanged after two parole denials. Unless a future board votes differently, she will spend the coming years in the same institution, with reviews every two years.

Readers who follow biography explainers on this site can also read our guide to Misha Ezratti’s wife, another widely searched name explained with verified facts only.

David Smith and the Boys’ Family

David Smith, the boys’ father, learned the truth along with the rest of the country in November 1994. His divorce from Susan was granted in May 1995, before her trial began.

He has opposed her release at both parole hearings and has said he will keep attending future ones. He told CNN in November 2026 that thirty-two years has not changed the heartache.

David later remarried and had more children. In interviews, he continues to speak about Michael and Alex and about keeping their memory at the center of every parole review.

Susan Smith in Popular Culture

The case has been revisited in documentaries, books, and television dramas for thirty years. David Smith published his own account, Beyond All Reason, in 1995.

A 1995 episode of Law & Order, titled “Angel,” was based on the case. The prison drama Oz also based its character Shirley Bellinger on Smith.

The case is still cited in discussions about false reports, media coverage of missing children, and how quickly public sympathy can turn when a story collapses.

Susan Smith FAQs

Is Susan Smith still in prison?

Yes. She remains incarcerated at the Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, South Carolina, serving two concurrent life sentences. Parole was denied in 2024 and again in November 2026.

What was Susan Smith’s sentence?

A jury convicted her of two counts of murder in July 1995 and rejected the death penalty. She received two concurrent life terms, with parole possible after 30 years.

When was Susan Smith denied parole?

Her first parole hearing was held on November 20, 2024, and the board denied parole unanimously. Her second hearing, on November 19, 2026, also ended in a unanimous denial.

Where is Susan Smith imprisoned?

She is held at the Leath Correctional Institution near Greenwood, South Carolina. She was transferred there after beginning her sentence at the Camille Griffin Graham Correctional Institution in Columbia.

When could Susan Smith be eligible for parole again?

After a denial, she can be reconsidered every two years. Following the November 2026 decision, her next parole review is expected in 2028, when the board will assess her case again.